Skip to content

Best Neighborhoods to Stay in New York, From Midtown to Long Island City

0 0
Nov 20, 2026
Rate this Blog: 

In short: For a first trip to New York, stay in Midtown Manhattan between roughly 34th and 59th Streets, because more subway lines meet there than anywhere else and Central Park, Times Square and the Empire State Building are all walkable. Pick Lower Manhattan if the Statue of Liberty and the 9/11 Memorial lead your list, SoHo or the Village for food and shopping, the Upper West Side for a calmer family base, and Brooklyn or Long Island City when the budget matters more than the view.

New York City has five boroughs, but almost every visitor sleeps in Manhattan or just across the East River in Brooklyn or Queens. The decision is less about safety or "the best" area than about which subway lines run past your door, because a well-placed hotel on the right line saves an hour a day. This guide compares six bases on transit, price level and character, then shows how each one connects to the sights and airports. You can see everything we cover about the city on our New York travel guide, and once you know the area, our trip planner builds a day-by-day route around it.

Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens in one table

The table sums up each area in one line. Price level is relative: Manhattan hotels are among the most expensive in the United States, so "lower" still means a large bill.

AreaCharacterPrice levelMain subway linesBest for
MidtownOffices, theaters, crowds, big hotelsHigh, wide range1, 2, 3, 7, A, C, E, B, D, F, M, N, Q, R, W, SFirst visit, short stays
Lower ManhattanFinancial District, harbor, quiet after darkMid to high, weekend deals1, 2, 3, 4, 5, A, C, J, Z, R, WStatue of Liberty, 9/11 Memorial
SoHo and Greenwich VillageCast-iron streets, boutiques, restaurantsHigh, few budget roomsA, C, E, B, D, F, M, 1, 6, N, R, WCouples, food and shopping
Upper West SideResidential brownstones beside two parksMid to high1, 2, 3, B, CFamilies, museum lovers, repeat visits
Brooklyn (Downtown, DUMBO, Williamsburg)Waterfront, neighborhoods, nightlifeMid, some bargainsA, C, F, 2, 3, 4, 5, L, J, M, ZSecond visits, longer stays
Long Island City, QueensNew towers, skyline views, few sightsLower than Manhattan7, E, M, G, N, W, RBudget travelers, JFK and LGA access

Two patterns stand out. Areas with many lines cost more, and areas that empty out at night, like the Financial District, tend to have lower weekend rates because the business travelers who fill them during the week have gone home.

Midtown Manhattan

Crowds crossing a street at Times Square in Midtown Manhattan under digital billboards at sunset

Midtown stretches from about 34th Street up to the southern edge of Central Park at 59th Street, and from the Hudson River to the East River. Inside it sit Times Square, the Broadway theater district, Rockefeller Center, Grand Central Terminal, Bryant Park and the Empire State Building. Penn Station, the arrival point for trains from Newark Airport and the Long Island Rail Road from JFK, is on the southern edge.

The practical case for Midtown is the subway. Times Square–42nd Street alone is served by the 1, 2, 3, 7, N, Q, R, W, S and, through a passageway to Port Authority, the A, C and E. From one station you can ride to Lower Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens and the Upper West Side without changing trains, which matters when you have three or four days.

The trade-off is noise and bulk. The blocks around Times Square are packed with people until after midnight, and many hotels there are large towers with small standard rooms. If that sounds tiring, look at the East Side near Grand Central or Murray Hill, or at the blocks west of Eighth Avenue in Hell's Kitchen, where Ninth Avenue is lined with inexpensive restaurants and the streets calm down after the theater crowds leave. Our own pick for a special occasion at the park's edge is The Plaza on Fifth Avenue at 59th Street.

Eating near a Midtown hotel

Avoid the chain restaurants facing Times Square itself. A short walk west, Ninth Avenue in Hell's Kitchen has dozens of small places from Thai to Turkish, and the classic Jewish delis of Midtown serve pastrami sandwiches large enough for two. Koreatown, the single block of West 32nd Street between Fifth Avenue and Broadway, stays open late.

Lower Manhattan for the harbor and the Statue of Liberty

Lower Manhattan skyline seen through the cables of the Brooklyn Bridge with a visitor at the railing

The southern tip of Manhattan holds the Financial District, Wall Street, the 9/11 Memorial and Museum, One World Trade Center and Battery Park, where ferries leave for Liberty Island and Ellis Island. The Whitehall Terminal next door is the Manhattan end of the Staten Island Ferry, which runs 24 hours, costs nothing and takes about 25 minutes each way past the Statue of Liberty. Walk east and you reach the Manhattan end of the Brooklyn Bridge.

Hotels here are mostly newer conversions of office buildings, with bigger rooms than Midtown at similar or lower prices, especially from Friday to Sunday. Fulton Center is the main subway hub, linking the 2, 3, 4, 5, A, C, J, Z and the R and W at Cortlandt Street.

The weakness is evenings. Once offices close, some streets of the Financial District get very quiet, and the restaurant choice is thinner than in SoHo or the Village. Tribeca, just north, fixes this with more dining, though at a higher price.

SoHo, Nolita and Greenwich Village

Nineteenth-century cast-iron buildings at the corner of Grand Street and Crosby Street in SoHo, Manhattan

SoHo, the area south of Houston Street, is known for its 19th-century cast-iron facades and its flagship stores along Broadway, Prince Street and Spring Street. Nolita to the east is smaller and more residential, and Greenwich Village to the north has Washington Square Park, jazz clubs and tree-lined side streets. Chinatown and Little Italy border SoHo on the southeast, so dumplings and noodle shops are a short walk away.

Rooms here are fewer and dearer than in Midtown, and many are in boutique hotels with a strong design focus. This is the area for travelers who would rather spend the evening walking to a different restaurant each night than queueing at a famous sight. It also sits between Midtown and Lower Manhattan, so both are one subway ride away on the A, C, E or the 1.

The drawback is weekend crowds on the main shopping streets and a lack of big-name sights within the area itself. Families who want space and a park nearby may find it cramped.

Is the Upper West Side good for families?

Aerial view over Central Park toward the apartment blocks of the Upper West Side and the Hudson River

The Upper West Side runs from 59th Street to about 110th Street, between Central Park and Riverside Park on the Hudson. It is a residential neighborhood of apartment buildings and brownstones, with the American Museum of Natural History on Central Park West and Lincoln Center at its southern end. Across the park on Fifth Avenue is The Metropolitan Museum of Art, reachable on foot through the park or by crosstown bus.

Families like it because two large parks are close, supermarkets and pharmacies are everywhere, and the sidewalks are less crowded than in Midtown. The 1, 2 and 3 run under Broadway down to Times Square, and the B and C follow Central Park West.

The limitation is that most sightseeing is south of you, so allow time for the ride downtown, and hotel choice is smaller than in Midtown. The Upper East Side, across the park, offers a similar residential feel near the big museums, served by the 4, 5, 6 and Q.

Brooklyn for more space per dollar

Cobblestone side street with brick buildings and trees in Brooklyn, New York

Brooklyn is a borough of about 2.6 million people, so "staying in Brooklyn" means choosing a part of it. Three areas suit visitors. Downtown Brooklyn has the most hotels and the best connections, with the 2, 3, 4, 5, A, C, F and R all within a few blocks. DUMBO, below the Manhattan and Brooklyn bridges, has the classic skyline views and Brooklyn Bridge Park. Williamsburg, one stop from Manhattan on the L, is the bar, music and restaurant district, with weekend food markets in warmer months.

Rates are often lower than comparable Manhattan hotels, and rooms are often bigger. You also get an evening life that feels local rather than built for tourists. Walking back to Manhattan across the Brooklyn Bridge is one of the best free things to do in the city.

The cost is time. Most Manhattan sights are 20 minutes or more away by subway, and late-night service on some lines is less frequent. Brooklyn works best for a second visit or a stay of a week or more.

Why consider Long Island City?

Long Island City sits on the Queens side of the East River, directly opposite Midtown. It has grown quickly from an industrial district into an area of residential and hotel towers, and Gantry Plaza State Park on the waterfront gives one of the widest views of the Midtown skyline. MoMA PS1, the contemporary art affiliate of the Museum of Modern Art, is here too.

The selling point is price and position. Hotels are usually cheaper than in Manhattan, and the 7 train from Vernon Boulevard–Jackson Avenue or Hunters Point Avenue reaches Grand Central and Times Square in just a few stops. Queens Plaza and Court Square add the E, M, R, N and W. The neighborhood is also on the Queens side for trips to LaGuardia and JFK.

The weakness is atmosphere. Some streets near the hotels still feel half built, sights are few, and dinner options thin out away from Vernon Boulevard. Treat it as a place to sleep, not to spend your days.

How long does it take to reach the sights from each area?

The matrix below lists the subway route we would use from each area's main station to each sight. All rides cost one fare of $3 with OMNY or a contactless bank card, including free transfers between subway lines. We give routes rather than minutes because journey times vary a lot with service changes, especially on weekends; check the MTA app on the day.

FromCentral Park (59th St)Times SquareStatue of Liberty ferry (Battery Park)The MetJFK Airport
MidtownWalkWalk1 train to South FerryWalk through the park or Q to 86th StE to Sutphin Blvd, then AirTrain
Lower ManhattanA, C or 1 north1, 2, 3 or R, W northWalk4 or 5 to 86th StA to Howard Beach, or E to Jamaica, then AirTrain
SoHo and the VillageA, C, E or 1 northA, C, E or 1 north1 train south6 to 86th StE to Sutphin Blvd, then AirTrain
Upper West SideWalk1, 2, 3 south1 train to South FerryWalk across the park or crosstown busE from 50th St area, then AirTrain
Downtown BrooklynA, C north2, 3 north4, 5 to Bowling Green4, 5 to 86th StA to Howard Beach, then AirTrain
Long Island CityN, W or E7 to Times Sq7, then 1 southE then 6, or N, W then QE to Sutphin Blvd, then AirTrain

Two short notes help with planning. The Staten Island Ferry from Whitehall is free and gives a good view of the statue without landing on the island. Ferries that actually land on Liberty Island and Ellis Island leave from Battery Park and need a separate ticket, so book ahead in summer.

From the airports to each base

From JFK, AirTrain JFK costs $8.75 and runs every 5 to 15 minutes to Jamaica, for the E, J and Z subway and the Long Island Rail Road, or to Howard Beach for the A train; the AirTrain ride itself takes about eight minutes. The E from Jamaica is the simplest ride to Midtown, Long Island City and SoHo. The A from Howard Beach suits Lower Manhattan and Downtown Brooklyn. The Long Island Rail Road from Jamaica to Penn Station or Grand Central Madison is faster than the subway but costs a separate train fare.

A yellow taxi from JFK to anywhere in Manhattan runs on a flat fare of $70, plus a $0.50 state surcharge, $1.00 improvement surcharge, $2.50 congestion surcharge south of 96th Street, a $2.00 airport access fee, a $0.75 congestion pricing toll south of 60th Street and a $5.00 rush-hour surcharge on weekdays from 4 p.m. to 8 p.m., before tip and tolls. That comes to $76.75 off peak and $81.75 at rush hour, plus the congestion toll where it applies. Taxis from LaGuardia use the meter with a $5.00 surcharge and the same $2.00 airport fee. From Newark, AirTrain Newark connects with NJ Transit trains to Penn Station, which suits Midtown best.

What a New York stay really costs beyond the room rate

The nightly rate you see on a booking site is rarely what you pay. Here are the extra costs that apply to every area.

ItemAmountNotes
NYC hotel room occupancy tax5.875% of the room rate plus $2.00 per room per night (rooms of $40 and up)Charged in addition to sales tax
Sales tax on hotel roomsApplies on top of the city hotel taxCheck the final price, not the headline rate
"Destination" or "facility" feeVaries by hotelCommon in Manhattan; read the booking terms
Subway or local bus$3 per rideFree transfers; OMNY caps at $35 after 12 paid rides in 7 days
Express bus$7.25 per rideRarely needed by visitors
AirTrain JFK$8.75 each wayChildren under five ride free
JFK taxi to Manhattan$76.75 off peak, $81.75 rush hourBefore tip and tolls

The OMNY cap is worth understanding. Since January 2026 the base fare is $3, and once you have paid for 12 rides on the same card or phone within a rolling seven-day period, further subway and local bus rides are free for the rest of that period. Use the same card or device for every tap, or the rides will not count together. A visitor staying in Brooklyn or Long Island City and riding three or four times a day will hit the cap quickly, which narrows the gap with a pricier Manhattan hotel.

Prices also follow the calendar. The weeks before Christmas, the New Year's Eve period around Times Square and big events such as the New York City Marathon push rates up sharply across Manhattan. January and February are usually the cheapest months, and the Financial District drops further at weekends. If your dates are fixed around the holidays, our guide to New Year in New York City covers the Times Square logistics in detail.

Which area fits which traveler?

First-time visitors with three or four days should stay in Midtown and accept the crowds; you will walk to half your list and reach the rest without changing trains. If you want the same convenience with quieter nights, the East Side near Grand Central or Hell's Kitchen on the West Side are good compromises.

Families with young children usually do best on the Upper West Side, with Central Park and the Natural History Museum on the doorstep and quieter streets for tired kids in the evening. Lower Manhattan is the second choice, thanks to bigger rooms and the harbor parks.

Couples and food lovers tend to prefer SoHo, Nolita or the Village, where the evenings are as good as the days. Travelers on a tighter budget should compare Long Island City and Downtown Brooklyn with the cheapest Midtown options, remembering to add the time spent on the subway. On a second or third visit, a week in Williamsburg or DUMBO shows a side of the city most short trips never see.

Visitors with limited mobility should check station access before booking. Many older subway stations still have no elevator, so a hotel near an accessible station, which the MTA marks on its map, can matter more than the neighborhood itself.

Problems to plan around

Room size surprises many visitors. Standard rooms in older Manhattan buildings can be very small, and photos rarely show it, so check the square footage listed on the booking page if space matters.

Weekend subway changes are frequent. Lines are often rerouted or suspended overnight and at weekends for maintenance, so a hotel near a single line is more exposed than one near a hub. The MTA app shows planned work, and staying near two or more lines gives you a backup.

Weather shapes the choice too. Summers are hot and humid, so a long walk from the subway to your hotel is harder in July, and winter storms can slow the airport trip. In both seasons, being close to a station is worth more than a slightly cheaper rate further out.

Noise is constant in Midtown and parts of the Village. Ask for a room on a high floor or away from the avenue if you sleep lightly. Finally, many hotels add a daily destination fee that is not in the headline rate, so compare total prices rather than nightly figures.

Booking your New York stay

Start with the sights you most want to see. If the list is Times Square, Broadway and the Empire State Building, book in Midtown. If it is the harbor, Ellis Island and the Brooklyn Bridge, book Lower Manhattan or DUMBO. For walking the elevated park of The High Line, Chelsea and the West Village put you at either end. Our list of the top attractions in New York helps rank them, and our piece on the islands of New York City covers day trips by ferry. When the area is settled, the trip planner can turn your list into a route that starts and ends at your hotel.

How we researched these neighborhoods

On 20 November 2026 we took subway and bus fares from the MTA fares page and the seven-day cap and January 2026 fare change from the MTA's 2025 fare change summary. AirTrain fares and frequency come from the JFK Airport AirTrain page, and taxi fares from the NYC Taxi and Limousine Commission, both read the same day. The hotel tax rate is from the NYC Department of Finance's 2025 hotel tax report. Station and line details were cross-checked against the Wikipedia articles on Long Island City and the Staten Island Ferry. We did not quote nightly hotel prices because they change daily; the price levels in the table are relative. We will recheck fares when the MTA next changes them.

NYC hotel neighborhoods: reader questions

Q. Is it better to stay in Manhattan or Brooklyn on a first visit?

Manhattan, for most people. You save travel time every day and can return to the hotel between sights. Brooklyn makes more sense on a longer or repeat trip.

Q. Is it safe to walk around at night in these areas?

The areas in this guide are busy, well-lit residential and commercial districts where visitors walk at night all the time. Use the same care you would in any large city, and keep to lit streets near stations late at night.

Q. Can I pay for the subway with my foreign bank card?

Yes. Contactless Visa, Mastercard, American Express and phone wallets work at every OMNY reader. Check whether your bank charges a foreign transaction fee on each tap.

Q. Do children pay on the subway?

Up to three children 44 inches tall or shorter ride free with a paying adult on the subway and local buses.

Q. Is Times Square a good place to stay with kids?

It is convenient but very crowded and loud. Many families prefer a hotel a few blocks away, or on the Upper West Side, and visit Times Square in the evening.

Q. Should I stay in New Jersey to save money?

Jersey City and Hoboken have cheaper hotels and PATH trains into Manhattan, but PATH uses a separate fare, so subway transfers are not free. Add that to your comparison.

Q. How far in advance should I book a New York hotel?

For the December holidays, New Year's Eve and marathon weekend, book months ahead. For most other dates, two to six weeks gives a reasonable choice.

Q. Which area is best for Broadway shows?

Midtown West, around Times Square and Hell's Kitchen, puts most theaters within a 10-minute walk, so you can skip the subway after a late show.

Q. Are short-term apartment rentals an option?

New York strictly limits rentals of whole apartments for less than 30 days, so most short stays have to be in hotels or with hosts who are present. Check the listing's terms carefully.

Q. Is it worth paying more to be near Central Park?

For families and runners, often yes. Morning walks in the park and easy access to the big museums make up for the higher rate.

Q. What is the cheapest way from JFK to my hotel?

AirTrain JFK plus the subway: $8.75 plus one $3 fare. It takes longer than a taxi with luggage but costs a fraction of the flat taxi fare.

Updated 20 November 2026.

Need help?

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Getting there

John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) is the main airport for New York.

General

Timing & weather

Written by

482 articles Writing since 2022

Md. Aminur Rahman is the founder and CEO of bookingMentor, which he started in 2011. He combines a background in technology with years of travel, including trips to remote destinations well away from the usual tourist routes, and he photographs many of the places he writes about.

He writes and edits the site's guides to destinations, visas, festivals and trip planning for travelers from around the world. Facts in each guide, such as prices, dates and entry rules, are checked against official and reputable sources before publishing and reviewed when they change.

More articles by Md. Aminur How we research our guides

React to this article

Your feedback helps us create better content.

People's Reactions

See how others feel about this article

  • 0 People love
  • 0 People feel so so
  • 0 People didn't like it
0 Comment
0 Reaction
Guest Not signed in

Join the conversation. Sign in to share your thoughts on this article.

Sign in to comment
{{item.get_author.first_name}} {{item.get_author.last_name}}
{{ moment(item.created_at,'YYYY-MM-DD').format("MMMM DD, YYYY") }}

{{item.comment_txt}}

{{item_reply.get_author.first_name}} {{item_reply.get_author.last_name}}
{{ moment(item_reply.created_at,'YYYY-MM-DD').format("MMMM DD, YYYY") }}

@ {{item_reply.reply_to}}, {{item_reply.reply_txt}}

@ {{item.reply_to}}

Blog You Might Like

Travel Update: What You Need To Know!

Roaming the world one adventure at a time: Travel tales, tips, and inspiration for wanderlusters.

Longest Hiking Trails in The World

  • No ratings yet
  • 0
  • 06/12/2022

Is York Worth Visiting? A Day-Trip and Two-Day Guide

  • 0
  • 11/15/2026

The Longest Hiking Trails In Australia

  • No ratings yet
  • 0
  • 06/12/2022

Subscribe